Board set up to improve banking culture 'rigged' in industry's favour: John McGuinnness

The new board set up to improve banking culture is "rigged" in favour of the lenders and not customers, one of the industry's biggest critics has claimed.

Fianna Fáil TD and chair of the Oireachtas Finance Committee, John McGuinness said he lacked faith in the Irish Banking Culture Board (IBCB), which appointed 14 board members earlier this week.

The IBCB as set up with the aim of restoring public trust in the banking system following the €1bn tracker mortgage scandal, and is chaired by former Court of Appeal judge John Hedigan.

The tracker mortgage scandal, which happened when almost 40,000 customers were wrongly put on more expensive loans by more than a dozen lenders, led to calls among political figures and consumer advocates for a change in how customers were treated

The new entity is being funded by the five main retail banks of AIB, Bank of Ireland, Ulster Bank, Permanent TSB, and KBC Ireland, leading to critics already questioning its credibility.

Mr McGuinness said: "I was disappointed with the makeup of the new board because one of the things we learned during the whole tracker issue is that the banks will rush to stack the house against the individual. So you are dealing with a rigged deck of cards here.

"This is paid for by the banks and when I look at the membership of the board, with all due respects to all of them, I see it weighs heavily towards the banks. I don't see the consumer represented in the significant way that I would have expected. If you are changing the culture within the bank, the first thing you'd like to see is banks giving up ownership of it and allow people who are critical and who have a role to play in bringing about the transparency that is needed."

The board includes senior figures of major banks including Ulster Bank chief Jane Howard, but also figures such as Padraic Kissane, the financial adviser credited as one of the main figures in exposing the tracker scandal.

More on this topic

ECB: Pricing policy on ‘right course’

New KBC Bank chief says he's ‘comfortable’ with Irish share of mortgage market

Five banks fined €1.07bn by European Commission over foreign exchange cartel

Probe as borrowers in arrears hit with legal fees

More in this Section

Google confirms Huawei block to ‘comply with US order’

Ryanair says profits down more than a quarter

Google ‘blocks Huawei from using apps on phones’

Auction politics back with a vengeance


Chelsea Flower Show feeling Brexit sting

Scientists say you really, really shouldn’t use homemade sunscreen from a recipe on Pinterest

Spoilers: Game of Thrones finale problematic in both plot and execution

The Earth's magnetic north pole is shifting rapidly – so what will happen to the northern lights?

More From The Irish Examiner